Sunday, 26 May 2013

Security Fencing in 28mm

Introduction

Exactly a month ago, I asked on The Miniatures Page if anyone knew how to make cranked fence posts out of MDF or any other cheap material.  I had a desire to build a fenced army camp (see also my Quonset huts) for an upcoming game of All Things Zombie.  Now, many gamers build chain-link fences from simple uprights such as bamboo skewers and these look fine from a distance.  However, I wanted to go a step further than this and model something that would bear a closer inspection.

It turns out that it's not hard for someone with a laser cutter to process a small, custom job - as long as you provide them with the source file for your design.  In this case, the parts that I wanted were very simple shapes and both Corsec Engineering (USA) and Minibits (UK) offered to cut them for me.  I went with the UK company, solely on the basis that the postage costs should be lower.  A couple of weeks later, after a few exchanges of e-mails with Leon at Minibits to determine exactly what would be done and how much it would cost, I received a bag of parts in the post.

The Build


Now I was excited; I had all the parts to make my fences - or did I?  It was immediately apparent that I hadn't thought about how I would base the fence posts.  OK, this was easily sorted: I cut out a series of 1" wide strips of MDF for basing.  These were of varying lengths: some were 6" and some 12".  I am nervous about warping in the longer lengths; so far so good - but only time will tell for sure.  I also cut out a pair of 'L'-shaped 90 degree corner bases.  The edges of the bases were chamfered roughly to remove the obvious 3mm step.

Next, I wondered how to fix the posts.  Initially I had thought of pinning them, but a quick experiment showed that the thin MDF posts were far to fragile to drill holes in.  Instead, I sank holes at 1.5" intervals along the centreline of the bases to act as sockets.  This does, of course, reduce the height of the posts by a couple of mm, but the joint is then quite secure.

OK, the uprights were now glued in (taking a lot of care to make sure that they were vertical!) and supports were fixed to every 3rd post.  Then it struck me: how do (authorised) people or vehicles get from one side of the fence to the other?  I'd completely overlooked the need for a gate!

So, a quick improvisation here: the gate section needed a larger gap than normal between the posts.  Also, the gates needed to hinge.  To that end, I added a couple of short pieces of tubing to each of the inner supports.  The gate pieces themselves would have some bent wire sticking out of the side; this would rest in these tubes and allow the gates to swing freely.  The 2 parts to the gate itself had to be scratch-built and this took quite a lot of effort.  It would have been much simpler had these also been laser-cut MDF, but that hadn't occurred to me at the time!

Adding the Chainlink

While I was considering what to use for the chain link mesh, my wife handed me a piece of fine plastic net that had blown into our garden from somewhere.  It's the sort of material that is used for veils at weddings, or perhaps for advanced flower arrangements - I'm not really sure.  "Would this be any use?" she asked.  "Perfect", I thought.

I'd already found some thin brass wire from which I intended to make the barbed wire runs.  This brass wire had been woven around a wine bottle originally, but I'd saved it just in case it was ever needed.  I used an old technique for modelling barbed wire: wind the wire into a tight coil, flatten the coil and pull it straight (but leaving in the kinks).

So, here's my first completed piece.  This is OK, so far as it goes, but there are some issues with it:
  1. The home-made barbed wire strands are a bit crude.  I'm not happy with them.
  2. The plastic mesh has been sprayed grey.  However, that was difficult to do because the small piece of netting was very lightweight and would try to float away when I sprayed it!
  3. The thin netting was hard to attach evenly to the posts, so as to eliminate any sagging.
  4. The completed structure is rather flimsy and probably won't stand up well to the rigours of tabletop use.  If I were making static scenery for model railways then this wouldn't be a consideration!

The Final Version

 It's hard to reverse course in the middle of a model-making project.  By this time, I'd attached plastic mesh to most of the fence pieces.  However, I decided that the thin net just wasn't working the way I wanted, so I removed all of it.

Instead, I replaced it with the traditional aluminium mesh, though sprayed and dry-brushed to soften the colour a bit.  For the wire strands, I remembered that I had a roll of model barbed wire from Gale Force 9, bought for some occasion just like this.  Once the decision was made, finishing off the fencing was very quick.

There is more vegetation on the inside of the compound than on the outside, on the basis that there may be grazing animals on one side but not the other.  I also modeled one section of fence as broken down, though curiously the way the wire has been wrecked suggests that something from inside the base has broken through.  I wonder what it was that escaped!

Cost for this project was £5 for the custom-made MDF posts, £4 for aluminium mesh, £4 (ish) for GF9 barbed wire, plus small amounts of paint, glue, static grass and MDF bases that I had lying around.  So maybe £14 in total, for which I have over 6 feet of fencing.  Was it worth it?  I think so, but you'll have to decide for yourself!




32 comments:

  1. They look really good. I've been looking at making fences for quite a while, but this has inspired me to actually do so.
    I've thought of using the plastic mesh bags that satsumas and the like use and would be a bit heavier than your veil-type mesh, but the aluminium stuff is the way to go.

    What dimensions are the posts ?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I though initially that the aluminium mesh would be too heavy-looking. Also, the plastic mesh was free! However, the aluminium doesn't really cost that much and it really works much better, I think.

      Delete
    2. Ah, yes - dimensions. Each post is 42mm high (37mm to the angle, then the cranked top adds another 5mm of height and 10mm of lateral).

      Delete
  2. Replies
    1. Thanks, Barks. I'm quite pleased with it, but it'll need a game or 2 to see how flexible my basing is.

      Delete
  3. Looks really good. I would have immediately gone to aluminum mesh and your experiment confirms my suspicion of plastic mesh. I also would have put a coil of "razor" wire along the top. That is fairly common here in the states. But just nit picking. Very nice terrain feature and on a manageable budget.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, razor wire coils would also have worked. Less common for industrial premises, more so for military ones, I think. A sensitive army base would probably have several rolls of razor wire on the ground outside the fence as well, but I didn't want to go that far!

      Delete
  4. They look great mate, they put my fences to shame lol

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Well, if your fences work for the games you play then I'd say there was nothing wrong with them!

      Delete
  5. Those fences look excellent, and fairly cheap too! I may have to copy your method of making these in the future.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. They're not hard to make, as long as you have fence posts of the right shape. I'm mildly surprised that these aren't already available commercially, but it wasn't at all difficult to have them cut specially.

      Delete
  6. Great job on these and the finished article looks superb. Colour me impressed!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Bryan. I'd had the idea for making these for a long time, but never did anything about it. However, I really need such fencing for the next part of my ATZ campaign - it's been far too long since I did much of that...

      Delete
  7. Great job buddy, Where did you pick up the mesh from?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I found the mesh from Halfords, in the car body repair section. Mind you, looking for "fine aluminium mesh" on eBay or other shopping sites suggests that it's quite easy to obtain.

      Delete
  8. That's a great big WOW. Fabulous job.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Irqan. I am pleased with how they turned out.

      Delete
  9. I've made similar for necromundia, but mine are now almost 20 years old!
    I used a plastic like mesh from a DIY store for repairing screen windows. I got a lot, about 4yds for $10 at the time. I actually did fix the window screens too and still have a few feet and scraps in my huge bit box!
    Very nice work on yours though! I like purchasing nice terrain bits, but nothing compares to seeing your own well done efforts on the table!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, I've heard about screen window mesh before, though I don't think such material is readily available in the U.K.
      It does take extra time to make your own terrain (compared with purchasing it), but you are guaranteed to get it just as you want it!

      Delete
  10. Damn fine work sir - colour me impressed!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, this seems to be the general reaction. But as I've said before on other articles, it's not actually that hard to do :-) .

      Delete
    2. And what difference should it make to us if it's hard or not? the fact is that you've made it and we're impressed! Accept the praise without question!!!!

      ;)

      Delete
  11. It was worth it, nicely done, and well done on changing your mind part way through to get a better finish.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Dave. It's always a bit of a wrench to undo work that I've already done, but in this case I think the result was much better for it.

      Delete
  12. those are really cool, I am going to have to steal theses

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, c80. It's a bit more work than the common "bamboo skewer" posts (and more fragile, too!), but I'm glad I made my fences this way.

      Delete
  13. These are excellent! Would you mind if I stole these too?

    Do you think Minibits would do a repeat order of your fence posts?

    Mark

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Go ahead, please!

      I'm sure that Minibits would be open to a request for a repeat order. Be aware that the MDF posts are quite fragile; Leon advised me that cutting them in plywood would cost a lot more. Since then, I've wondered if soaking each post in white glue would strengthen it, or just warp it. Might be worth an experiment with a spare piece.

      Delete
    2. Enquiry sent! These look too damn fine to not give them a try myself. Sorry for stealing though. I really appreciate the work you put into them.

      Stefan

      Delete
    3. You're welcome, Stefan - glad you like the fencing!

      Delete
  14. I've spent ages trying to work out the best way to make fences - then I stumble upon your blog, and bingo - there's the answer. The laser-cut mdf is the missing part in my puzzle! Thank you so much for sharing - the fencing looks fantastic - exactly what I need!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Great! I'm delighted that you found my article to be useful!

      Delete