Thursday, 8 August 2013

Building Disaster

Introduction

We often use blogs to show off our best work - I suppose that's to be expected - but rarely do we exhibit our mistakes.  Here's an example of something that has gone very wrong...

The Build

For a large part of Spring this year, I used my evenings to construct these buildings.  They're from Stoelzel's Structures and would have formed part of a car dealership, along with the garage that I haven't yet printed out.  On the left is the showroom (the shell only; I hadn't got as far as fittings & furniture).  The other, less complete, model is the carwash.

Now, I'd intended that these models would be built to a very high standard.  They'd have opening doors, transparencies for windows, no exposed foamcore edges and so on.  I spent a lot of effort to get to the stage you can see here.

Summer Heat

I had been making the dealership in my conservatory, where there was a great deal more space than on my overloaded workbench.  However, something distracted me for a few days and I didn't make any progress on the builds.  This coincided precisely with the start of one of the hottest summers on record for this part of the world.

The conservatory on my house is south facing (northern hemisphere) and it can get very hot if not opened up during the day.  Indeed, some years ago we were out for the entire day; when we returned we recorded a temperature of 50 degrees Centigrade!

When I next looked at my models, I was horrified to discover that the foamcore had started to delaminate.  This isn't a case of my printed paper sheets coming unstuck, but rather the outer card of the foamcore coming away from the inner foam.  Oh, bother!


Attempt at Recovery

At this point, I took a deep breath and thought about what I might do to fix the problem.  My first attempt to stick the card back to the foam (using white PVA/Elmer's) didn't really work; the glue wouldn't adhere to the inner core.

So, I tried again with a contact adhesive.  Initially, I thought this had been successful, but it soon became obvious that the glue had melted the inner core.  Even though I'd spread it as thinly as I could, the foam had collapsed and left a very uneven wall.

In despair

So there you have it - a sorry tale of woe!  It's been a couple of months now since this disaster occurred and I cannot figure out how to fix the models.  They're quite unusable as it stands, in my opinion.

It would probably be less effort to just start over rather than attempting to patch up all the damaged parts.  On the other hand, I put a lot of effort into these and I cannot bring myself to just chuck them in the rubbish bin.  Not quite yet, anyway...

14 comments:

  1. I have a similar oven/conservatory problem. So glad I didn't store my paints in there!

    In similar circumstances to yours, to be honest, I would probably just start again.

    If you do start again, maybe you can salvage some sections of the damaged walls to make some ruins or something smaller, like a bus shelter? It's a real wrench to give up on something you've worked so hard on, though.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'll need to take a closer look, but I think most of it would be more trouble to salvage than it's worth. You're right, it's a tough decision!

      Delete
  2. No idea what to suggest mate. TBH I'd just ignore it and carry on regardless. Its still looks far better than anything I've ever built

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, but I really don't think it's worth continuing with this. It's taken me 2 months to even talk about it, though...

      Delete
  3. Uggghhhhh..... I can tell you were off to a good start before this.

    What I've learned in the last two years, not all foam-core is created equal. I've seen brands where the "foam" is incredibly spongy and no well glued to the card, so that when I rabbet out parts, or cut, the foam is more likely to pucker away. The good stuff usually has a slight smacking sound as I cut it. Other than that, it is a bit hard to describe. I don't generally remember a lot of the brand names, but recognize the "inferior" (IMO) foam as being slightly grey rather than white. Since I'm at it, the other thing I prefer is the type with a rough papery card rather than the wax coated variety.

    This is the most extreme case I have ever seen. In cases where the printer paper has pulled away due to weak (cheap) spray mount, I often use a thin coat dab of hot glue along the edge and press it as flat as possible. Clearly in this case, the glue would need to be delivered into the center of the walls, like watered down PVA in a syringe, and then pressed flat.perhaps with a paper towel under it to catch drips, and wipe any obvious drips as you see them.

    Best of luck.
    Carl


    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Carl. I've already tried PVA; it won't stick to the foam. If only I hadn't left this stuff in the hot room!

      Delete
  4. Replies
    1. The good news is that our cacti *love* the conservatory and flower prolifically in the summer. They enjoy hot and dry!

      Delete
  5. That really is a bummer and I can't think of a solution. My usual remedy for things like this is glue and more glue. I use UHU (Poundland's best)for my foam card buildings and have managed to relamintate foam card using this method. Some clips to squeeze the outer card to the inner foam when glueing may help. For the latter I'd suggest pegs with a piece of scrap card on top and underneath to make a sandwich with the foam card in the middle. The card will help spread the pressure on the foamboard and shouldn't leave marks.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hmm - I'm using Bostik right now because I couldn't get Uhu in the right shop last time. I wonder if they'd behave differently on my foamcore? Might be worth an experiment, I suppose...

      Delete
  6. Wow, that is a bummer. If they truly can't be salvaged I would turn them into the ruins of what they are supposed to be. Hack out the delaminated bits and add weathering to it. Worth a shot if there headed for the bin anyway.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I hadn't thought of making ruins, though it seems kind of obvious. Maybe I'll give that a go - thanks!

      Delete
  7. that is very bad luck indeed. I don't use foamcore and focus on small buildings and strong paper. I know what disaster is, lately my vernish (which was very loyal to met80 flat from Tamiya) killed almost 7 miniatures with bubbles that dried. I had to repaint the lot and it really pissed me off. Finally it was a happy ending but a painting session lost.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I never had a problem with varnish, though one hears about it often enough. Common opinion seems to be that aerosol varnishes go cloudy if the weather is very humid.

      Personally, I am very careful to test any spray paint before using it, just in case I've picked up the wrong can!

      Delete