Yesterday was the date for Carronade 2015, the annual wargames show that is put on by the Falkirk District Wargames Club. I had never been to Carronade before, believing despite all the evidence that it was a very small, local show which wouldn't really have been worth the travel time. How wrong I was!
My younger son (A.) had expressed a desire to go with me to Falkirk and I had told him the previous night that he'd need to be up in plenty of time. As it was, I had to rouse him from his bed, though we still had plenty of time to catch the train from Helensburgh.
We changed from the local train at Glasgow Queen Street station and were fortunate enough to walk straight on to the inter-city just as it was about to leave. The itinerary I had printed off suggested that we wouldn't make this connection and would have to wait 15 minutes for the next train, so that was a bonus for us!
From Glasgow Queen Street to Falkirk High was only a short journey of 20 minutes or so. It took us slightly longer than this to walk from the station in Falkirk to the show venue in the local high school. During our walk, A. talked nonstop about Warhammer 40K. He and some friends have started playing small games at lunchtime in school once a week and he has visions of collecting and building at least 3 or 4 armies, if I understood correctly!
We arrived at Carronade marginally before the show's official start time, but the entrance was already open and so we didn't have to queue. It was immediately obvious from the site map that this was quite a big affair - I think there were 5 halls in use. At least, we visited 5 rooms during the day; if there were more then we missed something!
|Malifaux: my crazy doctor, creepy assistants and undead creations (bottom and left) vs. A.'s weird spiritualist, grey-suited bodyguards and pink, ethereal spirit hosts (top and right). All these models were very nicely painted indeed.|
So, I took a mad doctor and his entourage, whilst A. commanded a very refined-looking type of juju man and the possessing demons that he had summoned. All very odd, but although A.'s leader reached the magic hat that was the objective first, I wiped out all of his supports before he could escape with this treasure. Then my extremely powerful doctor took on the spiritualist one-to-one and slaughtered him.
This was the first time that I'd played Malifaux. My general impression is that there is a great deal of (very creepy) imagination in the figures and the setting. If you like that kind of thing then this will be heaven! However, the rules didn't particularly impress. Whilst the mechanism for using cards rather than dice (and being able to "cheat" by playing a card from your hand to override a drawn one) was well enough, the combat system and the special rules for each character seemed immensely complex. Each character card was dense with very small text, so perhaps not really suitable for casual, pick-up games.
WarpackPrince of Darkness Games. The main twist to this seems to be that each unit and each character is assigned a card every turn that details their melee, magic, missile and/or defence value. No dice are involved; the values on the unit's card are used for the entire turn.
In our game, my Orcs were thoroughly shot to pieces by A.'s superior Wood Elf archery. My depleted hobgoblin cavalry did manage to wipe out a cavalry unit with a flank attack and to run down an elven hero, but it wasn't nearly enough.
I'm not at all convinced by the diceless approach to games. What we were left with was a completely predictable combat resolution; once a unit's combat card had been revealed then all enemies knew whether it was worth attacking them that turn or whether they should direct their efforts elsewhere. That was married to a very traditional command/move sequence, where every unit could be moved at will up to its maximum distance each turn. Maybe I just didn't "get it", but I don't think I'll be playing this again.
LunchAs at a number of other wargames shows, the hot food on offer was basically chips. Yes, it was possible to put other yellow/brown food in the same dish (pie, burger, baked beans...), but there wasn't much outside of this genre. To add insult to injury, it was quite expensive. I keep hoping for better from school kitchens, but I'm continually disappointed. Why, oh why can't I remember to take my own packed lunch to these events?!
Escape from the Robot PlanetCrooked Dice stall, where I talked with Graeme at some length. More on my purchases later...
Just as we were about to move on, A. looked at a side table with some tiles and a deck of cards and said "Is that a demo game?" It was and so we were offered a 3-player run through the work-in-progress "Escape from the Robot Planet".
In this game, each player had to run from tile to tile, seeking for the exit that would allow them to escape. Cards could be played as either assists to the player's character or as hindrances to someone else, so there was a bit of tactical thought needed when choosing which effect from the card to use. I took great delight in playing a card to swap my hand with Graeme's, just after he had used a card to search through the deck for something he wanted!
Eventually, both A. and Graeme found the exit tile, whilst I was stranded at the other end of the board about as far away as possible. My card play to prevent Graeme from winning unwittingly left the way open for victory by A. instead, so my boy was pleased.
Overall impression: this was quite a fun little side game. Obviously it's still under development and the balance of card types might not be quite right. There seemed to be much backstabbing between the players, whilst the robots were all but bystanders; they didn't play much part in the game.
|Pacific Rim. Swordhead (?) in the centre has just ripped off Gypsy Danger's left arm|
Initially, 2 of the 3 monsters were submerged; they surfaced together to sandwich Gypsy Danger and one of them immediately tore an arm off the mech. However, the Russian and Japanese mechs came to our assistance and ganged up on Swordhead, eventually overpowering the beast. That left the damaged Gypsy Danger facing Leatherback (?) one-on-one. Both combatants took damage, but once we figured out that we had a chainsword and elbow rockets, we hammered the creature again and again. By the time the kaiju died, Gypsy Danger was fairly beaten up and had lost power in a leg as well as having massive dents in the torso. So, another win for our side!
ShoppingNo show report would be complete without the loot picture. Note that this is just my stuff; A. got some half-price Tau pathfinders for Warhammer 40K and some even more heavily reduced Magic cards.
So, what did I buy? A scenario book for 1809 Austrians vs French, more varnish, a second hand Dreadball team, some 28mm highland cattle, X-men dice, a bunch of 40mm Greek Peltasts (I intend to use them as giants to face my 28mm Argonauts) and a Crooked Dice transit van. This last will end up as the Mystery Machine, if all goes well.
Put together on the table like this, it doesn't look like much stuff. It cost enough, though!
Will I go to Carronade again? You bet I will! It's simpler for me to get to than any of the other Scottish shows and it's easily big & varied enough to satisfy my needs for a day out. My only regret is that we didn't have as much time as I might have liked to look at all the other games which were being displayed!
I like the loot haul, A good selection of swag! I did not know that CD made a transit. I shall have to look out for that.ReplyDelete
Glad you enjoyed the show and thanks for the report. A long way to go from Kent so I can't see myself making it!
Thanks, Clint. Yes, I'm now flush with stuff that needs to be read/built/painted/... :-) !Delete
The Crooked Dice transit van is hidden away under the "Heroes" section of their website: http://www.crooked-dice.co.uk/wp/product/transit-van/ . I'm particularly excited about this because Company B produce some "Mystery Machine" decals specially for this model: http://035f399.netsolhost.com/companyB_anime.html
Yes, Kent is a long way off - but if you're ever in the central belt of Scotlnd at this time of year then I'd recommend Carronade!
Glad you (and A.) had a good day. I always think the better the day the younger visitor has usually translates to the Dad - it can be a long day otherwise! I didn't get round to much of the the this year, with running a game) but is was certainly looking busy with great games. And as you conclude, well worth looking out the date for next years show.ReplyDelete
You're right about the kids making or breaking the day, Sam! My daughter (9) expressed a mild interest to come with use. While I would be delighted to take her to a convention, she hasn't shown much interest in my games at home. I think an entire day of this would bore her and we'd both have been miserable.Delete
Sounds like a great day out for the pair of you.ReplyDelete
Thanks, Herbert. It was indeed a good day - even though the games were average and the food distinctly sub-optimal. Sometimes it's just being out that matters :-) !Delete
You certainly did have "A Grand Day Out." Cracking stuff, Hugh!ReplyDelete
It was a fun day, though I do feel slightly guilty about appropriating a Yorkshire expression as my title :-) .Delete
Great father - son day! Impressive "sinking" QM2ReplyDelete
A. has already talked about the "next" show we go to. He's certain that he wants to do this again, so I've done something right there :-) .Delete
The warship, the Queen Mary 2 and lifeboats were (sadly) just decoration for the kaiju game. Perhaps that was a minor opportunity missed? It certainly was a striking piece!
Some great looking games and a nice haul as well!!ReplyDelete
Thanks, Ray. I've already noticed that other people's pictures of Carronade seem to concentrate on some of the large, historical games, unlike mine which are mostly of smaller, sci-fi or fantasy setups. There was plenty of variety!Delete
That looked like a great day out C6! Some cool games too. Good to see you passing the gaming torch onto the next generation. Nice haul as well dude!ReplyDelete
Thanks, Bob. Seems that most of the other blogs are oohing and ahing over the huge Battle of Hydaspes display game - on a sand table, no less! Ah, well, the games I played worked for us :-) .Delete
Yes, A. (12) is very keen on gaming at the moment. Long may it last!
Nice looking games! A significant loot haul still!ReplyDelete
Thanks, Simon. I think that I was a little disappointed with how some of the games played, though they certainly looked good!Delete