IntroductionLat weekend I played a small game of Full Thrust with my eldest son, primarily so that we could try out my Romulan fleet and see how the cloaking devices worked. I took an amended version of the same scenario to the last night at the games club; that will be reported in due course. In the meantime, here's how the tester went.
3 Romulan warships have just appeared (they can setup on any table edge in "their half" of the board) and are determined to stop the convoy. Let battle commence.
How did it play?Bractor and crushing the medium freighter Marie Celeste.
Then, the Romulan ships uncloaked and, sadly for them, each was virtually on top of their opposite number in the Ferengi fleet. The surprised captain of the heavy cruiser Krayton immediately opened fire, with devastating results. The Romulan cruiser Dragon was hit in the engines and, just as bad, lost her torpedo launcher, while the light cruiser Decurion took hits to engine and cloaking device. Ouch!
In return, the best the attackers could do was to inflict minor damage on the large merchantman Empress of Orion and to cripple the light freighter Ivanhoe [she lost 3 of her 4 holds. Oddly, all of these were determined to be carrying personal grooming equipment - I guess those Ferengi really love their ear-lobe polish! Ivanhoe also suffered a non-critical hit, which came out as "make it up yourself". I decided that her robotic loading system had malfunctioned and was busy unloading the contents of the 4th cargo hold - desk lamps - into space].
To add insult to injury, the Bractor then gutted her opposite number - the Lorica - leaving the Romulan destroyer just a drifting, lifeless hulk.
Dragon attempted to fire on a merchantman, only to discover that it couldn't lock its phasers on target due to scanner damage. At least the cruiser's damage control parties had managed to repair the plasma torpedo launcher...
Dragon attempted to fire another torpedo, the weapon malfunctioned and flew off in completely the wrong direction.
Krayton and the Bractor.
ConclusionThe cloaking device and the torpedo use up a lot of the mass in these Romulan ship designs. That means they really cannot go head-to-head with an enemy warship of about the same size; they just don't have the same number of phasers and the like. Instead, they must rely on hidden movement to position themselves where they can shoot without much return fire. That's not what happened here!
[scenario adjustment - in hindsight, the convoy escorts should have had less firepower. Perhaps 3/4 or 2/3 of the points value of the attackers rather than parity with them.]
- Dragon (CA): destroyed
- Decurion (CL): limping away, engines damaged, warp drive and cloaking device inoperable.
- Lorica (DD): lost. Drifting, bridge smashed beyond repair and all decks open to atmosphere.
- Krayton (CA): undamaged
- Letek (CL): undamaged
- Bractor (DD): minor damage
- Empress of Orion (large freighter): minor damage
- Marie Celeste (medium freighter): destroyed
- Ivanhoe (light freighter): destroyed - warp core breach.
[Update: we ran this scenario again, with minor differences. Will it turn out any differently? See here: http://colgar6.blogspot.com/2013/07/full-thrust-klingon-honour.html]
Nice BatRep as always Hugh.ReplyDelete
@your son- That's funny the Romulans had the Romulan Ale. They should have used it right away. Get those Ferengi drunk.
In hindsight, you're quite right - they should have used the card. However they couldn't tell that it would be to their advantage. I'm thinking that this card is a bit weak in its effect. Perhaps the target should refill his/her hand with 1 fewer card than he/she discards?Delete
Hmm. I guess I don't understand the cloaking device mechanism. It also looks like they de-cloaked showing their rears to the Ferengi. As a side note, when I first read the title I thought it said "Never Thrust a Ferengi."ReplyDelete
A ship that cloaks has to write its movement orders for all the turns ahead up to the point where it decloaks, so it has to guess where the enemy will be 'n' turns ahead. In this case, the player got it disastrously wrong.Delete
As for your other though, let's not go there. It sounds like a really bad idea :-) !
Nice scenario and good read C6 and as always with one of those moments that crack me up (in this case "ear lobe polish"). It appears on the surface that the Romulans should have a surprise advantage, even given that the convoy is of a comparable size. The cloaking device though doesn't seem to give enough of an advantage given its cost.ReplyDelete
Would giving the Romulans a more significant advantage when they uncloak be feasible ? I thought that maybe the Romulans decloak sequentially and fire first in each case, giving the "defenders" the choice to shoot at the first uncloaked one or waiting for the others to uncloak.
The cloaking device is a tricky feature to use effectively; this report demonstrates how *not* to do it, really! The secret is to outguess your opponent and manoeuvre your ships into positions where they can fire without taking much in return. In this case, the player used it to avoid one turn of medium-range fire, but overestimated the hostile warships' speed and de-cloaked right in front of them.Delete