Last week, I described my reworking of a scenario for Full Thrust: The Tesserae Incident. It's basically a Klingon commando raid on a secretive Romulan research base. Initially, the attackers have overwhelming force, but the defender's reinforcements arrive steadily; how much time can the attackers afford to retrieve the secrets from the installation?
As I see it, the Klingons have a number of key decisions that they need to take early on:
- The Romulan plasma torpedos are nasty, area-effect weapons but they can be degraded with concentrated firepower. Will the fleet split up and try to pre-position itself to attack any Romulan ships that uncloak? Is it better to split up and limit the number of ships that could be hurt by a single weapon, or should the Klingons stick close together, guard the assault carrier and try to shoot down any incoming torpedoes?
- How much should the Romulan base be bombarded before the commandos assault it? Too little and the base's point defences and security troops will still be at full effect; too much and there may be no loot left for the commandos to retrieve.
- The assault shuttles can carry either marines or loot. How many should be assigned to each function? Too few marines and the klingons won't capture the base - but there's no point in taking the research centre if the attackers cannot then retrieve anything of value.
For the Romulans, these issues arise:
- Should any of the early reinforcement ships drop their cloaks and appear on the table? It might provoke a Klingon response and distract them from their task, or it might just sacrifice the Romulan ship.
- Assuming that the Romulan fleet wish to uncloak en-masse, in which turn should this occur? Too soon and they might be outnumbered; too late and the Klingons will have accomplished their task and be heading for outer space.
Here's how it went when we played the game:
In our game, the Klingons decided to come in at high speed (typically 16" or so). Shuttles were launched and the warships surged forwards.
There wasn't a lot for the Romulans to do on turn 1, but I realised with delight that one of the enemy frigates was just in extreme range for the base's heavy beam battery. A runaway series of '6's ended up causing 9 points of damage to the tiny ship which was completely vapourised [in Full Thrust, a beam weapon that rolls a '6' not only inflicts damage, but also gets to roll again]. So, a bad omen for the Klingons, or just an extremely lucky shot?
The Klingons continued to approach at high speed. Anticipating a bombardment, the base switched on its Reflex Field (thus prohibiting it from shooting). However, the attackers also held their fire...
An ever-increasing number of "blips" was beginning to worry the Klingons, Romulan reinforcements were arriving, but there wasn't much the attackers could do about this except carry on with their plan.
The main event of turn 3 was the ground assault on the Romulan base as the troop-carrying shuttles arrived at their destination. Here's how it went:
- 12 Klingon shuttles (loaded with 10 squads of commandos) stormed the base.
- 3 shuttles from Red Group were shot down by point defence fire. Remaining = 9 shuttles, 7 commandos.
- The survivors all attempted a combat landing on the base. Red Group touched down successfully, but Blue Group suffered a disaster. One shuttle clipped a hill when making a low approach; it somersaulted and exploded. 2 other shuttles attempted to avoid the flying wreckage and instead collided with each other [of 9 dice thrown for the 2 groups, 3 came up with a '1' - an appalling result for the Klingons]. Remaining = 6 shuttles, 5 commandos.
- The 5 Klingon assault teams engaged the 5 base security squads. Honours were even and 3 of each fell. Remaining = 6 shuttles, 2 commandos, 2 base security.
Still there were no Romulan ships on the board, though there were blips all over the place. The assault on the planet was taking too long (and the outcome was too evenly balanced).
In an act of desperation, the Klingon battlecruiser "Relentless" fired everything it could as it flashed past the planet at high speed. The base lost one living quarters (and the associated scientists), but more importantly the volley knocked out all of the facility's fire control systems and killed one base security squad. At least that was very much in the Klingon's favour!
Things looked better for the commandos now that they had a 2:1 advantage in surviving troops. However, the Romulan commander (i.e. me) then played a Vengeance! event card. Sadly, even though the last base security squad fought with redoubled strength, they didn't manage to do more than trade losses with the Klingons. Result = 6 shuttles, 1 commando squad left. No base security remaining, so the last Klingon assault team captures the base (just)!
As the Klingon ships executed high speed turns away from the planet, the Romulan fleet decloaked! The defending ships were travelling relatively slowly, hoping to sandwich the invaders in the middle of the table. Whilst that wasn't quite how it turned out, they were still fairly well positioned.
Realising that the Romulan cruiser "Dragon" was perfectly positioned to attack his assault carrier, the desperate Klingon played an event card on her. Normally, this card ("The engines willnae stand it!" would be used on a friendly ship, but the Klingon was hoping that the Dragon would break down. It was an interesting gambit, but it wasn't to be; the Dragon's chief engineer was too canny to over-stress his engines in this manner.
The Klingon ships took evasive action, but it wasn't enough. The Dragon's plasma torpedo just clipped the Ragnarok (the assault transport) and rocked the vessel. Damage was severe, including a warp core critical hit. Before damage control teams could react properly, the Ragnarok blew up in a spectacular display of pyrotechnics!
Turns 6 and after
The Klingons were in real trouble now. Their battlecruiser (Relentless) had flown off the table; it's high speed and relative lack of maneuverability meant that it couldn't turn tightly enough to stay in the battle. Even though the 6 assault shuttles left the planetary base full of captured equipment, technicians and documents, the loss of the troopship meant that they would find it extraordinarily difficult to escape.
Events were played on the Romulans whenever possible, at least until the Klingon player ran out of cards, but they only slowed down the inevitable end.
Finally, the Romulan battlecruiser Consul torpedoed the last remaining Klingon cruiser. Although the Valhalla survived that attack, she was very heavily damaged and didn't have any realistic chance of either escaping or of fighting back. We played another turn after this, but it was obvious that the Klingons could do nothing to change their fortunes.
- Romulans: only minor damage to any ships. Research base heavily damaged and sabotaged.
- Klingons: Valhalla (CA), Ragnarok (assault carrier) and Victory (FG) destroyed. Relentless (BC) and Warrior (FG) escaped. 6 shuttles still at large and filled with important data about Romulan weapons research, though hiding in a system deep in Romulan space.
Could the Klingons have won this scenario? The game went quite heavily against them, yet they did suffer some bad luck:
- The flak from the base was probably average, but the shuttles' combat landings were spectacularly bad! Had more commandos made it into the base then the Klingons might have captured it a turn earlier; this would have made their escape more likely.
- The plasma torpedos performed well above average (again! I'm beginning to wonder if the Romulan's secret weapons research is really about increasing the yield from a torpedo, rather than anything else). In particular, the troop transport was horrendously unlucky to take a double threshold check from 1 torpedo and thence pick up a critical hit which resulted in her immediate destruction! Had she survived, albeit damaged, the game might have ended very differently.
- The Relentless couldn't manoeuvre enough to stay on the table; she was travelling too fast to turn in time. That's not really bad luck, but rather a misjudgement on the part of the Klingon player. Had their most powerful asset still been around when the ship-to-ship combat began then the Klingons might have put up a better fight!
So, could you do better as the Klingon? Would you have changed the force composition (perhaps having 2 smaller assault transports might have worked better)? What changes to tactics might have improved their odds? I'd be most interested to hear your thoughts - and I'd be absolutely delighted if anyone else also played this scenario and reported their results!
It seems a good game.ReplyDelete
the Klingon had a very bad timing but a strategy that could have worked. They could have sacrificed from the beginning the screening ships so the shuttles could leave.
This game was never going to be easy for the Klingons, but it could have been so glorious if they had succeeded!Delete
Quite a rough encounter for the Klingons, as I suspected it would be, but the loss of the Relentless due to bad handling couldn't have helped.ReplyDelete
Great aar, as always C6.
My kids always seem to forget that ships just don't turn too well at high speed. I hope that they figure this out before they start learning to drive, if that ever happens!Delete
Great report Colgar ... it was indeed a good day to die for the Klingons. But in a war of attrition, the Romulans would win hands down I think. :)ReplyDelete
Thanks, F.E.M. I'm wondering if a 1-turn delay in the Romulan reinforcements would have made the game a bit more equal?Delete